Taiwan's Conundrum

Here is a long article, but one worth reading, on the strange situation in Taiwan. Since the end of the Chinese civil war, the percentage of people on the island who consider themselves to be Taiwanese rather than Chinese has grown dramatically – but at the same time their willingness to die for independence seems to be declining. Morale in the Taiwanese military is seriously eroding:

Low morale is severely affecting Taiwan’s defense as the country faces a dramatic shortage in troops, with some combat units dropping below 80% staffing due to early retirements and discharges.

One of the lessons of the Ukrainian situation is that a small country on the borders of a much larger country cannot reasonably expect to achieve its aims militarily. DC Swamp Creatures might be happy to see other people’s sons & daughters sacrificed for their entertainment, but outnumbered technologically-outclassed US forces will clearly not be able to cross the wide Pacific and rescue Taiwan from neighboring giant China.

The obvious solution for Taiwan would be to seek a negotiated Quebec-type status within China – analogous to the Minsk agreements which were supposed to guarantee Donbas residents a form of self-rule within the Ukraine … until the Euros undermined that deal, with devastating consequences for everyone in the Ukraine.

How to get there from here?

At least the official US Government (not the evil Deep State) now would prefer not to have shooting wars. And all parties have an interest in not disrupting Taiwan’s world-leading chip-manufacturing facilities. Will Taiwan be able to avoid the Zelensky problem of a politician who promises peace but instead commits the island to an unwinnable destructive war? A lot rests on the decisions of the Taiwanese people.

The depths of Taiwan’s military morale crisis - Asia Times

4 Likes

The failure of the Minsk Agreements and the “one country, two systems” for Hong Kong should tell you that these kinds of arrangements don’t work out. Well, maybe it worked out for Quebec but that’s Canada — and China is no Canada. Taiwan is going to have to face the music, and in this case the music goes something like this:

3 Likes

We live in the real world, and not every problem has a wonderful solution.

Many years ago, President Eisenhower made a remark in a situation where there were no good choices that the best option was the “least unacceptable”.

As the Ukraine is in the process of proving, any attempt by Taiwan to resist China militarily would end in the destruction of Taiwan and its abandonment by the West. What is Taiwan’s “least unacceptable” alternative to that fate?

Taiwan, Japan, and the RoK, would be well served by obtaining several nukes apiece from India.

Too bad they have nothing to give India in return:

1 Like

nothing to give to India? Ramen

Not to be confused with Raman.